Scrum is a powerful framework - but it is not the right fit for every problem. Scrum is a flexible framework used for delivering products in complex environments. Scrum can help teams deliver value sooner by helping teams break down work incrementally. Scrum helps teams solve problems by fostering collaboration and reduces risk through iterative delivery.
But Scrum isn't the right fit for every problem space. Scrum shouldn't be used for predictable, repeatable work, and it shouldn't be used in an environment of absolute chaos. Instead, Scrum should be used in complex environments to deliver products with a clearly defined customer.
Predictable and Repeatable Work
If your work involves predictable, repeatable processes that can be documented and executed with precision, Scrum is not needed and in fact would be a waste of time. For example, Scrum might not be a fit in these situations:
Assembly line production: Where work instructions & standard operating procedures are used to drive efficiency and eliminate variability.
Routine maintenance tasks: Where established workflows are used to ensure consistency leaving no room for creativity.
In short, if you could write work instructions to do that thing, you shouldn't be using Scrum to coordinate the work.
Complete Chaos and Lack of Clarity
On the other end of the spectrum, Scrum may not be the answer in situations where chaos reigns and the basic elements of the product are undefined. For instance:
You don’t know what product you are delivering.
The customer is unknown.
Before introducing Scrum in such environments, it’s critical to step back and establish clarity. Start by:
Identifying your customer.
Defining the customer needs and what is the high-level understanding of the product or service to be delivered.
Once the chaos is under control and the work environment transitions into a more structured, complex space, Scrum may become a viable framework.
When Scrum Is the Right Answer
Scrum excels in environments where:
Creativity and problem-solving are essential: Delivering value requires applying knowledge, testing hypotheses, and iterating on solutions.
Uncertainty is high, but not absolute chaos: The end product or solution isn’t fully known at the start, requiring frequent inspection and adaptation.
Collaboration drives success: Cross-functional teams need to collaborate closely to deliver increments of value.
For example, developing a new software application, designing innovative products, or addressing complex market needs are scenarios where Scrum shines. The framework’s emphasis on transparency, inspection, and adaptation supports teams as they navigate uncertainty and solve problems creatively.
Conclusion
Choosing whether to use Scrum requires a realistic assessment of your work environment. Here are a few questions to ask yourself:
Is the outcome predictable and repeatable? If so, Scrum might not be needed.
Is the work chaotic and undefined? Take a step back to establish clarity before applying Scrum.
Does the work require creativity, collaboration, and iterative problem-solving? If yes, Scrum may be the perfect fit.
An honest assessment of your situation can help you apply the right solution approach for the problem space. Scrum is a great tool, but it needs to used in the right problem space to be effective.
Comments